Aishani Partners
BOAT v. BOULT: Delhi High Court on Res Judicata and the Limits of Successive Interim Injunction Applications

BOAT v. BOULT: Delhi High Court on Res Judicata and the Limits of Successive Interim Injunction Applications
Introduction
In the dispute between Imagine Marketing Pvt. Ltd. (IMPL), the proprietor of the well-known BOAT brand, and Exotic Mile (EM), the proprietor of the BOULT brand, the Delhi High Court recently evaluated[1] an important procedural issue: Can a party file a second interim injunction application seeking the same relief on the same facts that had not been granted earlier?
The Hon’ble Delhi High Court, in its judgement dated 6th July, 2026 dismissed the application seeking an injunction against the use of the wordmark ‘BOULT’, stating that a previous interim application was not maintainable on identical set of facts and IMPL is substantially seeking the same relief. In this regard, the Court also assessed the principles surrounding res judicata[2] and successive interim injunction applications under the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) while balancing with substantive trademark rights.
Brief Background
IMPL filed a suit in 2019 seeking a permanent injunction against EM for using a similar mark ‘BOULT’ and other alleged similar marks to IMPL’s BOAT in relation to electronic products which includes headphones, earphones, speakers and other related products. IMPL contended that the alleged mark ‘BOULT’ was deceptively similar and had similar logo and packaging in the same products range to ride upon IMPL goodwill.
In September 2019, the Hon’ble Delhi High Court had granted ex part ad interim injunction restraining EM from using the mark ‘BOULT’ or any other deceptively similar marks to that of IMPL registered trademarks BOAT/ boAt.[3] When EM sought vacation of that order, by judgement dated 21st January 2020, the Court held that that BOAT and BOULT were ‘phonetically similar’ but confining the operative injunction to the specified device marks and the tagline “Unplug Yourself.” In other words, the operative portion of the injunction did not restrain the use of the standalone wordmark BOULT.[4]
EM appealed before the Division Bench (DB). The DB in September 2025 upheld the restraint with respect to the device marks but set aside the restraint on the tagline. The DB also observed that IMPL did not seek any modification / clarification of the 2020 order with respect to the standalone word mark BOULT, not filed a cross-appeal. It was also noted that EM had subsequently rebranded to GOBOULT, and any challenge to GOBOULT would constitute a separate cause of action.[5]
Thereafter, in October 2025, IMPL filed the instant interim injunction application after 6 years from the passing of the judgment on 21st January 2020 seeking an ‘interim injunction’ specifically against the wordmark BOULT.
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiff’s Contentions
IMPL argued that the omission of the wordmark BOULT from the operative part of the judgement was an inadvertent oversight. It contended that the Court had earlier observation that BOAT and BOULT are phonetically and visually similar and that the ex parte injunction by the court as well as the appellate order justified a restraint on the use of the wordmark BOULT as well.
Reliance was placed upon Kaviraj Pandit Durga Dutt Sharma v. Navaratna Pharmaceutical Laboratories[6] and K.R. Chinna Krishna Chettiar v. Shri Ambal & Co.[7], which recognize phonetic similarity as a relevant consideration in determining deceptive similarity between competing trademarks.
On the procedural aspects, IMPL also relied on the principle that interim reliefs/ injunctions do not have absolute finality and may be revisited where the circumstances justify it.[8] IMPL also resisted EM’s pleas of res judicata and issue estoppel, arguing that relief against the word mark had not been expressly rejected on its merits. Reliance was placed upon Arjun Singh v. Mohindra Kumar and Others[9], Rakesh Madan and Another v. Rajasthan Financial Corporation and Others[10], which recognize that a party can seek variation or modification of an order.
Defendant’s Contentions
EM contended that the fresh relief sought IMPL (in October 2025) was same as claimed earlier and was declined by the 2020 judgement. Therefore, EM maintained the claims of res judicata and that the present interim application was filed for identical facts and relief is an abuse of the judicial process.
Reliance was placed upon S. Malla Reddy v. Future Builders Cooperative Housing Society and Others[11], K.K. Modi v. K.N. Modi and Others[12] and Arjun Singh v. Mohindra Kumar and Others[13],which recognizes that subsequent applications for the same relief on the same ground, after an earlier application has been disposed of declining the relief, constitutes an abuse of process of law[14].
Furthermore, EM added that they have discontinued the use of the mark ‘BOULT’ and rebranded to ‘GOBOULT’ and that no undue hardship was being caused to IMPL. It also highlighted that the online product listings relied upon by IMPL had been archived or relating to unavailable products.
Lastly, EM argued that IMPL cannot invoke the inherent powers of the Court (as provided under Section 151 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC)) at a much subsequent stage of the litigation, when the Court had already acted under the specific procedural framework (under Order XXXIX, R.1&2 of the CPC) governing interim injunctions.[15]
Decision and Analysis
The Hon’ble Delhi High Court dismissed the interim injunction application filed by IMPL in October 2025. The question before them was: ‘Whether the judgment dated 21st January, 2020 had restrained EM from using the wordmark BOULT?’. To this, the Court revisited the 2020 operative order and held that the restriction was on the usage of the specified BOULT device marks and not on the standalone word mark BOULT.’
Having found that IMPL did not file a cross-appeal nor established a case of changed circumstances or undue hardship and waited six long years to file the present application, the DB also noted that granting an injunction against the wordmark BOULT at this stage would effectively amount to rewriting both the Single Judge’s and the Division Bench’s judgments, which was beyond the scope of its jurisdiction.
The Court also addressed the principles underlying res judicata. Referring to Rakesh Madan, they noted that: even though the CPC imposes no prohibition on a second interim injunction application, yet the principles of res judicata under CPC may apply at successive stages of the same proceedings, though such principles do not operate with the same rigidity for interlocutory orders. So, where substantially the same relief is sought on the same facts after an earlier determination, the applicant should establish materially changed circumstances or undue hardships.[16] As per the Court, IMPL had not done either in the present case.
Concluding Remarks
The Imagine Marketing Pvt. Ltd. v. Exotic Mile judgement highlights the importance of procedural discipline in trademark litigation. While the Court in its 2020 operative injunction order highlighted the clear findings of phonetic similarity and dishonest adoption; but the gap to secure an injunction or correct the gap through review/ modification or cross-appeal to include the word mark BOULT proved fatal in order to attempt the same relief six years later.
The present judgement emphasized the importance to pursue appropriate procedural remedies at the proper stage rather than attempting to revive omitted relief through successive interim applications.
It is worth highlighting that the Court did not recognize an absolute bar against multiple applications seeking identical / similar reliefs under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 of the CPC. It rather examined the applicability of principles underlying res judicata to successive stages of the same proceedings, while pointing that Order XXXIX R. 4 of the CPC permits modification of interlocutory injunctions in appropriate circumstances, including where a material change in circumstances or undue hardship is established.
The Court emphasised that a subsequent application seeking substantially identical relief cannot be entertained on unchanged facts merely because the earlier operative order was unfavourable to the applicant.
Key takeaways
For brand owners, enterprises and legal practitioners, the key takeaways from this judgment are:
- It is vital to distinguish procedural outcomes from substantive findings. The operative order, and not merely favourable court observations, in litigation is critical and should be reviewed at the outset.
- Any omission or ambiguity in an injunction order should be raised and corrected at the earliest opportunity for a more favourable outcome.
- Principles comparable to res judicata can apply to repeated applications in the same proceedings.
- While there is no specific bar on a second injunction application seeking the same relief under the CPC, it is important to plead and support materially changed circumstances or undue hardship being caused to the applicant.
Contributed by: Aditi Verma Thakur and Arpita Tripathy
[1] Imagine Marketing Pvt. Ltd. v. Exotic Mile, CS (COMM) 519/2019; Judgment dated 6/07/2026
[2] Res judicata (Latin for “a matter judged”) is a legal doctrine that bars parties from relitigating a claim or issue that has already been decided. Also see: https://www.scribd.com/document/471844216/Res-Judicata-under-Civil-Procedure-Code ; https://legal.thomsonreuters.com/blog/what-is-res-judicata/#res-judicata-explained
[3] Imagine Marketing Pvt. Ltd. v. Exotic Mile, CS(COMM) 519/2019
[4] Supra Note 1, at ¶ 3
[5] Supra Note 1, at ¶ 7
[6] 1964 SCC OnLine SC 14
[7] 1969 (2) SCC 131
[8] Supra Note 1, at ¶ 8
[9] 1963 SCC OnLine SC 43
[10] 2009 SCC OnLine Del 39
[11] (2013) 9 SCC 349
[12] (1998) 3 SCC 573
[13] 1963 SCC OnLine SC 43
[14] Supra Note 1, at ¶ 11
[15] Supra Note 1, at ¶ 26
[16] Supra note 9.